Your logic is still flawed primarily because beauty is subjective. There are men who I think are gorgeous but mainstream America may not. Case and point: I am far more physically attracted to Yasiin Bey than Brad Pitt. Hasan Minhaj is cuter to me than Chris Hemsworth. Again, it is all subjective.
Hell, look at the last two widely publicized “most beautiful women” studies. Almost every single black woman with black features would be considered unattractive. So you factor in personal opinions, mainstream opinions and racism, and you have a mixed bag of what’s attractive. There are women and men who you probably think are gorgeous that I think are just meh.